GSI Banner
  • Free Access
  • Contributors
  • Membership Levels
  • Video
  • Origins
  • Sponsors
  • My Account
  • Sign In
  • Join Now

  • Free Access
  • Contributors
  • Membership Levels
  • Video
  • Origins
  • Sponsors
  • Contact

© 2025 Grey Swan Investment Fraternity

  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information
  • Whitelist Us
Swan Dive

When Trust Runs Thin, Markets… Rally?

Loading ...Addison Wiggin

September 16, 2025 • 5 minute, 41 second read


AIFed

When Trust Runs Thin, Markets… Rally?

The market keeps setting records as if mistrust itself were a growth sector.

The S&P 500 and Nasdaq both notched new highs yesterday after President Trump said trade talks with China were “going very well.”

Nvidia’s partner CoreWeave surged on a $6.3 billion AI infrastructure order.

But beneath the cheering, even Wall Street’s old guard is on notice. Mutual funds, once the ballast of retail portfolios, are losing ground to ETFs and direct indexing.

The Financial Times reported this week that executives overseeing more than $35 trillion are under pressure to pursue “bigger deals or deeper cuts” to stay relevant.

Meanwhile, the SEC said it’s prioritizing Trump’s call to end quarterly earnings reports. The president wrote on Truth Social that such disclosures “waste money, and distract managers from properly running their companies.”

Many CEOs, including Jamie Dimon and Warren Buffett, have long complained that quarterly reporting forces short-termism. Yet the CFA Institute warns that less transparency “reduces the accuracy of analysts’ forecasts” and leaves small investors flying blind.

These debates aren’t entirely academic. They are about whether retail investors can still trust the numbers in front of them.

📉 Trust in the Fed, Trust in the Market

Tomorrow’s Fed rate decision is the week’s main event. The central bank is expected to cut rates, but the real story is the institution’s independence.

President Trump’s attempt to remove Governor Lisa Cook was denied by an appeals court yesterday, ensuring she’ll remain in her seat for the vote. At the same time, the Senate confirmed Stephen Miran, Trump’s nominee to replace a departing governor.

The Washington Post noted that Trump has “repeatedly pressed Fed officials to lower rates” and openly challenged the board’s authority.

Bloomberg’s September survey of economists found that the majority are “somewhat or extremely worried” that the Fed’s decisions will be influenced by political loyalties.

If that happens, borrowing costs for the U.S. government rise as risk premia creep into Treasury markets.

Public confidence is already threadbare.

In 2001, 74% of Americans trusted Alan Greenspan to do the right thing. In 2025, only 37% say the same of Jerome Powell. For the first time, trust in Trump to manage the economy is higher than trust in the Fed chair.

🏛️ Trade, TikTok, and the Thin Red Line

The U.S. and China struck a framework for TikTok’s future during talks in Madrid.

Surprise, surprise: Trump called the deal “a win for America.”

The details—who controls the algorithm, whether Oracle’s Larry Ellison takes charge—remain unresolved. A final handshake is expected when Trump meets Xi Jinping on Friday.

Trade tensions remain the bigger issue. If you pose the question to trade advisor Jamieson Greer, non-tariff trade barriers are by far the greatest challenge to his team engaged in Trump’s “grand realignment”.

The Financial Times reports tariffs will expire in November unless a broader deal is struck.
China has halted U.S. soybean purchases, tightened rare earth shipments, and launched probes into U.S. chipmakers, accusing Nvidia of violating antitrust law in its 2020 acquisition of Mellanox. Nvidia insists it has complied “with both the letter and spirit of the law.”

🚗 Musk Buys Into Tesla

Elon Musk bought $1 billion of Tesla stock yesterday — his first open-market purchase since 2020 — sending shares up 3.26% and helping erase this year’s losses. Musk called it a “vote of confidence” ahead of a shareholder meeting that could approve a record-breaking pay package.

Not everyone was impressed.

“If that is the only thing that has value anymore,” the American Pope Leo weighed in on the deal, “then we’re in big trouble.”

Heh. Seriously.


🎄 A Lopsided Christmas

It’s 100 days until Christmas, but only a fraction of households are doing the heavy lifting.

According to Moody’s, the wealthiest 10% of Americans now account for 49.2% of all consumer spending — the highest since records began in 1989.

That explains how the economy has avoided recession even as delinquencies rise and job growth is revised sharply lower. Black unemployment climbed to 7.5% in August, twice the rate for White Americans, erasing years of progress.

Turn Your Images On

“The top of the distribution is propping up the entire consumer sector,” Moody’s chief economist Mark Zandi told CNBC. “That is not sustainable.” (Source: Moody’s and the Fed)

The Fed can trim rates, but it cannot restore balance when half the country is standing on the sidelines, with credit cards in hand.

⚓ Lessons from the Mayflower?

On this day in 1620, the Mayflower sailed with 102 passengers — half dissenters fleeing persecution, half entrepreneurs chasing fortune. Storms forced them off course, yet they built a settlement that endured because of a fragile but functional social compact.

There are a lot of wonky things about the Mayflower legend.

First, as folks in Provincetown, Mass., will tell you, the idea that the Pilgrims landed on a rock a couple of hours West of what is today’s Plymouth is geographically implausible.

Second, that the Pilgrims celebrated the first Thanksgiving. In fact, Thanksgiving as an official holiday was a much more grim reminder of the carnage and death at the Battle of Gettysburg some 243 years later.

Having grown up in New Hampshire, we were happy to claim the Pilgrims for their New England heritage.

Until, that is, we read a few books as an undergrad and discovered much of the mystique for religious freedom was bestowed during a period of time known to historians as The Great Awakening, in which Puritan descendants veiled their economic hopes and dreams for the New World in a cloud of religious freedom… during the 1830s.

Either way, if the story is accurate, 102 people boarded a boat in England in 1620 and crossed the cold North Atlantic by wind and sextant. There aren’t too many American souls who would give up their Netflix subscriptions to venture as such into the unknown.

The Pilgrims’ ship carried ballast in its hold to steady against rough seas.

Today, our markets and politics rely on a different ballast: trust. When people trust institutions, capital flows, innovation thrives, and societies endure shocks. When trust runs thin, even record stock indexes can tip and capsize.

The Mayflower reminds us: survival isn’t about perfect conditions. It’s about whether the ballast holds.

~Addison

P.S.: Grey Swan Live! this Thursday with Adam O’Dell: we’ll explore how the $10 trillion “cash bubble” in money markets will rotate during a new rate cut cycle. Adam’s thesis: It’s a massive transfer of wealth, and getting in ahead of the move could earn you a safe return. And as always, we’ll identify where individual investors can find their best footing when trust in the markets and money itself is on the line.

Turn Your Images On

If you have any questions for us about the market, send them our way now to: Feedback@GreySwanFraternity.com.


Grey Swan Forecast #6: China Annexes Taiwan — Without a Shot Fired

December 26, 2025 • Addison Wiggin

Our forecast will feel obvious in hindsight and controversial in advance — the hallmark of a Grey Swan.

Most analysts we speak to are thinking in terms of the history of Western conflict. 

They expect full-frontal military engagement.

Beijing, from our modest perch, prefers resolution because resolution compounds its power. Why sacrifice the workshop of the world, when cajoling and bribery will do?

Taiwan will not fall.

It will merge.

Grey Swan Forecast #6: China Annexes Taiwan — Without a Shot Fired
Grey Swan Forecast #7: A Global Debt Crisis Will Reprice Democracy

December 24, 2025 • Addison Wiggin

Wars, technology races, and political upheavals — all of them rest on fiscal capacity.

In 2026, that capacity will tighten across the developed world simultaneously. Democracies will discover that generosity financed by debt carries conditions, whether voters approve of them or not.

Bond markets will not shout so much as clear their throats. Repeatedly.

Grey Swan Forecast #7: A Global Debt Crisis Will Reprice Democracy
Seven Grey Swans, One Year Later

December 23, 2025 • Addison Wiggin

Taken together, the seven Grey Swans of 2025 behaved less like isolated events and more like interlocking stories readers already recognize.

The year moved in phases. A sharp April selloff cleared leverage quickly. Policy shifted toward tax relief, lighter regulation, and renewed tolerance for liquidity. Innovations began to slowly dominate the marketplace conversation – from Dollar 2.0 digital assets to AI-powered applications in all manner of commercial enterprises, ranging from airline and hotel bookings to driverless taxis and robots. 

Seven Grey Swans, One Year Later
2025: The Lens We Used — Fire, Transition, and What’s Next… The Boom!

December 22, 2025 • Addison Wiggin

Back in April, when we published what we called the Trump Great Reset Strategy, we described the grand realignment we believed President Trump and his acolytes were embarking on in three phases.

At the time, it read like a conceptual map. As the months passed, it began to feel like a set of operating instructions written in advance of turbulence.

As you can expect, any grandiose plan would get all kinds of blowback… but this year exhibited all manner of Trump Derangement Syndrome on top of the difficulty of steering a sclerotic empire clear of the rocky shores.

The “phases” were never about optimism or pessimism. They were about sequencing — how stress surfaces, how systems adapt, and what must hold before confidence can regenerate. And in the end, what do we do with our money?!

2025: The Lens We Used — Fire, Transition, and What’s Next… The Boom!