The Quality Stocks Index Is A Screaming Buy… For The Long Haul

The gap between high-flying tech stocks – soaring far beyond their earnings growth – and companies delivering slow, but steady growth, has reached an extreme last seen in 1999:

Turn Your Images On

Quality stocks are underperforming the overall market at levels seen in the late 1990s. (Source: Jeff Weniger via X)

The S&P 500 Quality Index ranks companies not by market cap or a compelling AI story, but rather by fundamentals. Earnings, profit margins, and financial leverage. Reasonable debt.

You know, the kind of stuff that makes your eyes glaze over. And the type of companies we like to hold for the long haul in our model portfolio.

Today’s underperformance in quality stocks is another sign that we’re in a cycle where tech earnings are driven by a story, not by fundamentals – classic signs of a bubble.

While most data points we’ve reviewed indicate the bubble is still in its early stages, the Quality Stocks Index at this extreme is a sign of a late-stage bubble.

Today’s Quality Index gives you another reason to take some profits off the table now, as we’ve prescribed in thePlunge Protection Plan.

~ Addison

P.S. We’ve invited New Yorker, Andrew Zatlin, to join this week on Grey Swan Live! for obvious reasons: we want to get a boots-on-the-ground look at what incited young voters to elect Zohran Mamdani, a democratic socialist, to office in the world capital of finance. It’s an entertaining subject, at the very least.

With customary aplomb, we expect Zat to regale us with his thoughts on Mamdani, the purported exodus of finance bros to Florida and Texas and what the Federal government shutdown revealed about unemployment and the real economy behind the AI capex spending bubble. More to come…

If you have requests for new guests you’d like to see join us for Grey Swan Live!, or have any questions for our guests, send them here.

The gap between high-flying tech stocks – soaring far beyond their earnings growth – and companies delivering slow, but steady growth, has reached an extreme last seen in 1999:

Turn Your Images On

Quality stocks are underperforming the overall market at levels seen in the late 1990s. (Source: Jeff Weniger via X)

The S&P 500 Quality Index ranks companies not by market cap or a compelling AI story, but rather by fundamentals. Earnings, profit margins, and financial leverage. Reasonable debt.

You know, the kind of stuff that makes your eyes glaze over. And the type of companies we like to hold for the long haul in our model portfolio.

Today’s underperformance in quality stocks is another sign that we’re in a cycle where tech earnings are driven by a story, not by fundamentals – classic signs of a bubble.

While most data points we’ve reviewed indicate the bubble is still in its early stages, the Quality Stocks Index at this extreme is a sign of a late-stage bubble.

Today’s Quality Index gives you another reason to take some profits off the table now, as we’ve prescribed in thePlunge Protection Plan.

~ Addison

If you have requests for new guests you’d like to see join us for Grey Swan Live!, or have any questions for our guests, send them here.

Sunday night, Powell addressed the probe head-on in a video post — a rarity. He accused the White House of using cost overruns in the Fed’s HQ renovation as a pretext for political interference.

The White House denied involvement. But few in Washington believed it.

What followed was bipartisan condemnation of the investigation. Greenspan, Bernanke, and Yellen co-signed a blistering rebuke, warning the U.S. was starting to resemble “emerging markets with weak institutions.”

Estimates now indicate that the average consumer will default on a minimum payment at about a 15% rate – the highest level since a spike during the pandemic lockdown of the economy.

President Trump’s proposal over the weekend to cap credit card interest at 10% for a year won’t arrive in time to help consumers who are already missing minimum payments.

Not to fret, the other 85% of borrowers continue to spend on borrowed time. Total U.S. household debt, including mortgages, auto loans, student loans, and credit cards, reached record highs in late 2025, exceeding $18.5 trillion. This surge was driven partly by rising credit card balances, which neared their own all-time peaks due to inflation and higher interest rates.

There’s an old Wall Street maxim: “Don’t fight the Fed.”

This year, you could add a Trump corollary.

A wise capital allocator doesn’t fight that storm. He doesn’t argue with it. He respects it the way sailors respect the sea: with preparation, with humility, and with a sharp eye for what breaks first.

In 2026, the things that break first are the stories. The narratives. The comfortable assumptions.

Total municipal, state and federal debt service costs soared to nearly $1.5 trillion in the third quarter of 2025. Debt’s easy to accumulate when rates are low. Trouble is, you are obligated to refinance them even after rates go up.

It’s also a key reason why the Trump administration is demanding lower interest rates – even if it means reigniting inflation.