Subprime Democracy

Raise your glass to the hard-working people
Let’s drink to the uncounted heads
Let’s think of the wavering millions
Who need leading but get gamblers instead

Spare a thought for the stay-at-home voter
His empty eyes gaze at strange beauty shows
And a parade of the gray-suited grafters
A choice of cancer or polio

—Salt of the Earth, Rolling Stones

We have said goodbye to 2024. Now, let us try to dope out the new year. But first, a yellow warning light appears. Breitbart:

Credit Card Defaults Spike to Highest Level Since Aftermath of 2008 Financial Crisis

Credit card lenders wrote off $46 billion in delinquent loan balances in the first three quarters of 2024, a 50 percent increase from the same period last year. These forms of write-offs are viewed as a highly monitored measure of loan distress. This is the highest level since 2010, according to industry data gathered by BankRegData. Mark Zandi, the head of Moody’s Analytics, said, “High-income households are fine, but the bottom third of US consumers are tapped out. Their savings rate right now is zero.”

What? Isn’t this the world’s greatest economy? Aren’t stocks near all-time peaks… and unemployment near all-time lows?

How could the working class be falling behind on its credit card payments?

All around us — except for the mainstream press, which is generally wrong about everything — upbeat commentary and popular euphoria invite optimism.. After all, Trump is soon back in the White House. Pete Hegseth is going to make our military more lethal than ever. ‘Border Czar’ Tom Homan is going to deport the rapists and killers back to Central America. Scott Bessent — a billionaire hedge fund manager — is sure to keep the economy humming along. And two of the world’s most clever billionaires — Musk and Ramaswamy — are going to make the feds more ‘efficient,’ thereby eliminating a $2 trillion annual deficit.

And yet, something is clearly going wrong.

While billionaires get richer, the uncounted heads… the wavering millions… are getting poorer. And what a coincidence; the rich also dominate Wall Street, the banking industry, the press, both political parties and the federal government.

We weren’t born yesterday. The feds produce nothing. So, every penny of federal spending (over $6 trillion in 2024) must come from The People. And every penny must go to other people… the people favored by the controlling elites. It is not surprising that they favor themselves.

Nothing new about this. But in the US, rascality seems to be entering a more flagrant phase… in which the outgoing president pardons his own son (after making an election promise not to do so)… and the incoming president rewards his powerful supporters with the top federal jobs.

In the beginning of a democratic republic, yes, politicians still pinched their secretary’s derrieres and skimmed money from public budgets. But at least they kept it quiet… and were generally ashamed when it came out.

Those old limits — both written and customary — kept those in power from taking too much from those not-in-power. Even kings and queens learned not to squeeze their subjects too hard, lest their own heads be put onto the chopping blocks. As Voltaire remarked, ‘the best form of government is a monarchy… with an occasional beheading.’

In a democracy, public executions of politicians are regrettably rare. As a deterrent, losing an election is not nearly as effective as losing a head. Besides, the system is so rigged up in favor of the ruling class that rarely do members of Congress lose their seats. In the most recent example, 96% of those up for election won another term, even though Congress has only a 15% approval rating. The voters have figured it out. Why bother to boot a scoundrel out of office, when another ‘grey suited grafter’ will just take his place?

We must now be arriving at some near-end stage of the democratic progress. The Constitution is ignored… deficits don’t matter… and the degenerates have become greedy and ruthless. Debt and inflation increase and real output goes down.

Federal appointees are no longer chosen on the basis of their competence, but on the degree of loyalty to the chief executive. That is, they are not expected to uphold the principles of the founders, but to find ways around the restraints in order to fulfill the Maximum Ruler’s agenda, whatever it is.

In a better system, a real leader… or a savvy monarch… would tell the people the truth — that the US is headed for bankruptcy. He would get out the chainsaw and hack away at federal spending until receipts equaled expenses.

But to everything there is a season. A time to be born and a time to die. We are somewhere in between. Too old to rock and roll; too young to die. America is not ready for a Milei-style revolution. Not ready for an American perestroika. Not ready for the chainsaw.

Instead, it chooses the gambler. He’ll want to keep the grift going for as long as possible, accumulating as much wealth and power as possible… while pushing the inevitable calamity as far as he can into the future.

We spare a thought for the salt of the earth…and hope for the best for the year ahead…

Stay tuned…

Regards,

Bill Bonner

Raise your glass to the hard-working people
Let’s drink to the uncounted heads
Let’s think of the wavering millions
Who need leading but get gamblers instead

Spare a thought for the stay-at-home voter
His empty eyes gaze at strange beauty shows
And a parade of the gray-suited grafters
A choice of cancer or polio

—Salt of the Earth, Rolling Stones

We have said goodbye to 2024. Now, let us try to dope out the new year. But first, a yellow warning light appears. Breitbart:

Credit Card Defaults Spike to Highest Level Since Aftermath of 2008 Financial Crisis

Credit card lenders wrote off $46 billion in delinquent loan balances in the first three quarters of 2024, a 50 percent increase from the same period last year. These forms of write-offs are viewed as a highly monitored measure of loan distress. This is the highest level since 2010, according to industry data gathered by BankRegData. Mark Zandi, the head of Moody’s Analytics, said, “High-income households are fine, but the bottom third of US consumers are tapped out. Their savings rate right now is zero.”

What? Isn’t this the world’s greatest economy? Aren’t stocks near all-time peaks… and unemployment near all-time lows?

How could the working class be falling behind on its credit card payments?

And yet, something is clearly going wrong.

In the beginning of a democratic republic, yes, politicians still pinched their secretary’s derrieres and skimmed money from public budgets. But at least they kept it quiet… and were generally ashamed when it came out.

We spare a thought for the salt of the earth…and hope for the best for the year ahead…

Stay tuned…

Regards,

Bill Bonner

The market seems to know something about private credit that we don’t. And in a big enough liquidity event for private credit, investors will have to sell off more liquid assets if they want capital.

That’s the danger private credit poses today, exactly at a time when rules are being eased to make it easier for retail investors like us to buy into this asset class.

I’m in the camp that this smells like a way to keep the party going by providing another source of liquidity – the passive investment flows from your regular 401(k) contributions. The smell takes on a sour note as this sector starts to falter.

Perhaps today’s selloff is simply a reaction to declining interest rates, the growth of private credit, and a few inevitable deals that have gone sour recently.

More money sloshing around in the system means daily life has gotten more expensive. Not rocket science.

We’ve all observed certain goods — TVs, laptops, the gadgets we don’t need but buy anyway — keep getting cheaper, often while getting better.

But the Big Four killers of household budgets: healthcare, housing, childcare, and education, are marching upward like a military parade.

Add Biden-era price-level stickiness and Trump-era tariffs whose full effects haven’t even landed yet, and you get the stew voters have been choking down.

Credit default swaps (CDS) are a tool that measures the cost to insure against a company’s debt.

A soaring CDS suggests that investors are demanding a higher return. The implication? That debt isn’t as safe as it may appear.

It’s also a sign that the liquidity crisis and dangers in the private credit market are starting to show up in the mega-cap companies that are raising debt to invest in AI and data centers. And if that starts a slowdown, it could mean that the stock market hits the brakes.

I’m obviously very biased against socialism. I don’t think socialism has solutions to these problems. I don’t think Mamdani particularly has solutions. I don’t think you can socialize housing. If you just impose rent controls, then you probably have even less housing, and eventually, it’s even more expensive.

But to Mamdani’s credit, he at least talked about these problems. So my cop-out answer is always to say: The first step is to talk about the problems, even if you don’t know what to do about them. There’s been a failure of, let’s say, the center left-center right establishment to even talk about them.